2024 Reject for major revision

Reject for major revision

Author: zzje

August undefined, 2024

WebMy personal definition of major-revisions as a reviewer is that I'm asking the author to do additional experiments or analysis, but if they do that work, the paper is suitable for publication. That's why I would expect a major-revisions decision to ultimately end up with a … WebAnswer (1 of 6): This happened to me once, though I was given a notional reason that they rejected if not happy after two rounds of reviews. In fact, I learnt that the reviewers were happy with the final version, and surprised to hear that it had been rejected. It went to another, but less highl...

When can a thesis get rejected or asked for a major …

Webinterest, or of major interest only if paper is substantially revised Minor errors (rounding errors; minor mismatch with text/tables/figures); •Components present but mayneedminor forreadability •Subject matter is original pressworthy,and important • components present; •Data are accurate and match text; •Well‐written, concise, clear WebApr 13, 2024 · In the 2nd revision, I could not understand the editorial manager paper status meaning. The paper status has changed from "major revision" to "with editor" after … gas that turns lime water cloudy

Reviewer responsibilities - Royal Society of Chemistry

WebMinor revisions - the best you can hope for after the first round of review Major revisions - the decision we received in this case Reject – clearly, the one you want to avoid; Editors are most likely to write back to you after initial review and recommend either ‘minor revisions’ or ‘major revisions’ to your paper. Web12 hours ago · The defence and foreign ministers of the Philippines and the US also met in Washington on Tuesday, the same day the two nations kicked off their largest war games in key areas in the Philippines. WebYou will normally be asked to indicate your recommendation (e.g. accept, reject, revise and resubmit, etc.) from a fixed-choice list and then to enter your comments into a separate text box. ... If recommending rejection or major revision, state this clearly in your review (and see the next section, 'When recommending rejection'). gas that off

China envoy asks Manila to reject Taiwan’s independence claims, …

WebMajor revision. Your article has a chance of being accepted, but the reviewers have requested substantial changes to be made. These changes are expected to take … WebAccept/Minor Revision/Major Revision/Reject in the questionnaire. Give specific feedback that enables authors to improve their work, erring on the side of constructive criticism, rather than falsely positive reviews that may result in later rejection and disappointment. Your report should be written in simple neutral language, gas that starts with a kWebI put "Major Revision" instead of "reject" for a very simple reason - "an interesting study denies some of the assumptions held by a certain audience" (Davis, M.S. (1971), “That’s interesting! david reid obituary 2022

"WebPapers having two reviewers’ recommendations to accept and minor revision have much greater chance of acceptance (more than 98%) than papers receiving two reviewers’ recommendations that include a major revision and a reject or two rejections (which results in an acceptance rate of less than 5%): (Figure 1). " - Reject for major revision

Reject for major revision

Web10 hours ago · Nurses reject UK govt pay offer and escalate strikes. Britain's main nursing union said Friday its members had rejected a government pay offer and immediately announced an escalation in strike ... WebYou will normally be asked to indicate your recommendation (e.g. accept, reject, revise and resubmit, etc.) from a fixed-choice list and then to enter your comments into a separate …

Did you know?

WebJun 15, 2024 · 文章目录背景1. Reject2. Major Revision3. Minor Revision4. Accept背景在投国际会议（如AAAI、IJCAI）时，一般会收到邮件直接告知你结果是 Accept 或者 Reject。 … Web首先，如果投稿的SCI论文icon拿到了“大修”（major revision）算是一件值得恭喜的事情。. 虽然文章可能存在不少问题，但你的研究应该还是有一定的魅力，让编辑和审稿人给了这 …

Web2 hours ago · 8 Mins Ago. LONDON - Britain’s main nursing union said on Friday its members had rejected a government pay offer and immediately announced an escalation in strike action. Hopes had been high ... WebDec 4, 2024 · An editor may use “reject with option to resubmit” to mean “revise and resubmit” for a number of reasons: To emphasize that the revisions required are (seriously) major, going well beyond what would typically be associated with a “major revision.”. The editor wants to make it clear that the authors need to write a new paper, not ...

WebIn this case, the editor may choose “Reject and Resubmit” rather than “Major Revision” for the manuscript decision. Do not treat this as a rejection and get depressed—it is an … WebAug 19, 2024 · Yes, a good examiner will read the thesis line by line. There are five possible outcomes from the examination of a thesis. Accepted without corrections. Minor …

WebEditor of a journal asked for "Major Revision" for a submitted paper, after submitting revised paper it went for the review, after that the status shows "with Editor" for some time. Now, again it ...

WebReject （棄却）– 明らかに良くありません。でも、どのように改善することが出来るかのコメントが付いてくる場合があります。 minor revisionとmajor revisionは、査読後の編集者が下す最も一般的な決定です。 gas that\u0027s about one percent airWebWherein an editor rejects an article but invites you to resubmit later, presumably with what is basically major revisions. Response: Reject and resubmits are situations where the … david reid north carolinaWebAug 22, 2024 · For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it … gas that you breathe outWebSCI论文Major Revision的状态指的是什么？SCI论文发表的过程是需要审核的，每个审核阶段都会显示一个状态。Major Revision指的是论文大修的意思，发表SCI论文反复修改是很 … gas that turns lead acetate paper black david reid rate my professorWebDoes major revision mean rejection? After extensive editing, the work may be rejected.When you submit your article after significant modification, it is allocated to the same reviewers … gas that\\u0027s about one percent airWebOct 1, 2012 · 49. In my field (chemistry), the practice is: for those journals that make a clear distinction between minor and major revision requests, “major revision” means that the … gas that wakes you up